Industrial water cooling can be achieved in one of four ways dependent on your required process water temperature:-

EVAPORATIVE COOLING TOWERS

To cool water to within 3°C of wet bulb ambient.

thumbs up

ADVANTAGES

  • Low capital cost
  • Lower power consumption

DISADVANTAGES

  • Has to be registered with local authorities
  • Requires water treatment which can be expensive
  • Has to be cleaned twice per year
  • System water loss
  • Corrosion
  • Contamination of water circuit.
thumbs down

DRY AIR COOLERS

At best will only cool water to within 3°C of ambient. However, the greater the temperature difference, the cheaper the plant.

thumbs up

ADVANTAGES

  • Moderate capital cost
  • Low power consumption
  • Little or no water treatment
  • Low maintenance
  • No water loss
  • Possible heat reclaim

DISADVANTAGES

Will only cool to within 3°C of ambient which in the summer for a few days for short periods will be 30°C or higher.

thumbs down

WATER TO WATER COOLING

To cool water to within 3°C of existing source.

thumbs up

ADVANTAGES

  • Minimal capital cost
  • Very low power consumption
  • Little or no water treatment
  • Minimal maintenance
  • No water loss

DISADVANTAGES

You must already have a source of cool water i.e., ring main of chilled water with surplus capacity.

thumbs down

REFRIGERATED WATER CHILLERS

To cool water/glycol to any temperature below ambient.

thumbs up

ADVANTAGES

  • Stable water temperature independent of ambient
  • Little or no water treatment
  • No water loss
  • Possible heat reclaim

DISADVANTAGES

  • High capital cost
  • High running cost
thumbs down